Skip to main content

The Economic Cost-benefit Analysis of Black Soldier Fly as an Alternative Animal and Fish Feed Ingredient in Malawi

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
MwAPATA Institute
Co-authors

Maggie G. Munthali, Lemekezani Chilora, Mike Goliath, William J. Burke, M. Eric Benbow, Jeremiah Kangʼombe & Andrew Safalaoh

Date of publication
Edition or Version
1.00
Institution
MwAPATA Institute
Language
Gender marker
Youth marker
Description/Abstract

Insect farming is a high-potential emerging farming enterprise in sub-Saharan Africa and their production has a relatively small ecological footprint. Black Soldier Fly (BSF), Hermetia illucens, is a promising insect species for a sustainable and innovative alternative protein source in animal feed. Little or no evidence exists showing whether BSF is a viable alternative sustainable feed ingredient in aquaculture and animal feed in Malawi or an economically feasible option for farmers. The objective of the study is to evaluate the financial feasibility of BSF farming at various scales of production using Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) with data collected from a small-scale pilot BSF farm in Lilongwe. The study addressed the following research questions: (a) What are the costs and benefits of farming BSF in Malawi for (i) small-scale farming (individual farmers, clubs, and cooperatives), and (ii) large-scale commercial farmers? (b) What drives variation in the benefit/cost ratio (BCR) of BSF farming across scales? (c) How could policies improve BCRs of BSF farming to support adoption in Malawi? The indicators used to assess the economic viability of BSF farming for smallholder and commercial farmers in this study included Net Present Value (NPV) and Benefit Cost Ratio. Results imply BSF farming is viable and feasible across scales of production. Small-scale farmers will generate roughly MK507,100 (US$ of gross revenue for one larval cycle and MK2,535,500 (over $2,500) annually. Commercial farmers can generate MK1,536,100 for one larval cycle and MK7,680,750 annually. Sensitivity analysis shows BSF farming remains profitable even within a 10% variation in the cost of production, the price of outputs, and the yield of BSF larvae and frass.

Other Partners

Michigan State University, LUANAR.

Keywords
Cost-benefit Analysis, Black Soldier Fly, Animal and Fish Feed, aquaculture, Hermetia illucens, smallholder, commercial farmers
Contact name (for further information)
Dr. Maggie Munthali
Contact email (for further information)
Contact phone (for further information)
+265999237333
Contact institution (for further information)
MwAPATA
Citation

Munthali, G., Chilora, L., Goliath, M., Burke,W.J., Benbow, M.E., Kangʼombe, J., & Safalaoh, A. (2003). The Economic Cost-benefit Analysis of Black Soldier Fly as an Alternative Animal and Fish Feed Ingredient in Malawi. Working Paper No. 23/01. MwAPATA Institute. Published by MwAPATA Institute, Lundu Street, Off Chayamba Road, Area 10/386, P.O. Box 30883, Capital City, Lilongwe 3, Malawi.

CCARDESA Category

Agricultural Diversification Challenges and Opportunities in the Malawian Groundnut Value Chain

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
MwAPATA Institute
Co-authors

Dinah Salonga, Anderson Gondwe, and Joseph Goeb

Date of publication
Edition or Version
23.00
Institution
MwAPATA Institute
Language
Description/Abstract

Based on production and export data, groundnut has the potential to contribute to Malawi’s agricultural diversification agenda, for both food and export purposes. According to key informants interviewed, the main challenges faced in the groundnut value chain are high aflatoxin contamination, limited access to improved seed, and limited access to structured markets. Policy options should focus on addressing issues that limit productivity and strategies for mitigating aflatoxin contamination considering their threat to food and nutrition security, public health, and access to higher-value markets. Future research should focus on how to best alleviate the identified constraints and harness opportunities for contributing to the country's agricultural diversification agenda not only in the groundnut value chain but also for other crops.

Other Partners

Agricultural Transformation Initiative (ATI) through the Michigan State University (MSU) Food Security Group

Keywords
agriculture production, export, groundnut, peanut, agricultural diversification, food, aflatoxin contamination, access to improved seed, agro-inputs, access to structured groundnut markets, policy options, nutrition security, public health,
Contact name (for further information)
Ndidza Chisanu
Contact email (for further information)
Contact phone (for further information)
+265999237333
Contact institution (for further information)
MwAPATA
Citation

Salonga, D., Gondwe, A., and Goeb, J. (2003). Agricultural Diversification Challenges and Opportunities in the Malawian Groundnut Value Chain. Published by MwAPATA Institute, Lundu Street, Off Chayamba Road, Area 10/386, P.O. Box 30883, Capital City, Lilongwe 3, Malawi.

CCARDESA Category

HOW TO DO NOTE ON DISSEMINATING MESSAGES THROUGH DIGITAL MEDIA

Author or Institution as Author
SAPP Malawi
Date of publication
Edition or Version
1.00
Institution
Department of Agriculture Extension Services, Malawi
File format
Language
Gender marker
Youth marker
Description/Abstract

The use of digital media in collection and disseminating information on various farming technologies and interventions has improved accessibility of information and feedback. It involves the collection and transmission of digitized content through the internet or computer networks and offline mobile applications (app). This includes text, audio, video, and graphics. The Agriv1(agriculture extension application) and Ulimi ndi Nyengo (web-based platform that transmits agriculture advisory services) were rolled out to perform stated actions. The agriculture extension applications and one of the social media platforms, Facebook were used in the dissemination of information through digital media. This form of technology through which information was shared provided end users or project beneficiaries’ easy access to vital information on interventions being implemented by the project.

Keywords
ICT, DIGITAL, MEDIA
Contact name (for further information)
Upile Faith Muhariwa
Contact email (for further information)
Contact phone (for further information)
+265993155272
Contact institution (for further information)
rexbaluwa@sapp.mw
Citation

SAPP Malawi (2003)How To Do Note On Disseminating Messages Through Digital Media

CCARDESA Category

Guidelines for Capturing Information and Knowledge Products for CCARDESA

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
CCARDESA
Co-authors

Stephen Opiyo and Fally Masambuka

Funding Partner
Date of publication
Edition or Version
1.00
Institution
CCARDESA
File format
Language
Gender marker
Youth marker
Description/Abstract

This document is about the Guidelines for Capturing Information and Knowledge Products for CCARDESA

Other Partners

IFAD

Keywords
Guidelines for Capturing Information and Knowledge Products for CCARDESA
Contact name (for further information)
Baisti Podisi
Contact email (for further information)
Contact institution (for further information)
CCARDESA
Citation

CCARDESA(2021) Guidelines for Capturing Information and Knowledge Products for CCARDESA (p88), Gaborone, Botswana

CCARDESA Category

Satellite Data for Improved Monitoring of Farm Productivity and Early Warning Systems in Botswana

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
Joshua Sikhu Okonya
Co-authors

Enock Warinda, Moses Odeke, Baitsi Podisi, Futhi Magagula, Cliff Sibusiso Dlamini, Andrew Farrow, Felicia O. Akinyemi, Reason L. Machete, Benedict Kayombo, Joseph Tuyishimire, Kenneth Mubea, & Wellington Michael

Date of publication
Institution
Digital Earth Africa
Language
Description/Abstract

Despite the adaptation and mitigation measures that have been put in place to counter the negative effects of climate change and food insecurity, more than 57.8 million people in the Southern African Development Community (SADC) population need food assistance in 2023 due to poor harvests (APA 2023). In Botswana, alone, close to 37,000 people need food assistance (FAO, 2022). This comes against the backdrop of declining agricultural productivity attributed to several factors including high cost of inputs, high incidence of pests and diseases, low input use and extreme weather conditions such as droughts, floods, and erratic rainfalls (FAO 2022).

Keywords
Satellite Data, Climatic Shocks, Adaptation, Mitigation, Limited technical capacity, science-policy
Contact name (for further information)
Joshua Sikhu Okonya
Contact email (for further information)
Contact institution (for further information)
Association for Strengthening Agricultural Research in Eastern and Central Africa (ASARECA)
Citation

Okonya, J.S. Warinda, E. Odeke, M. Podisi, B. Magagula, F. Dlamini, C. S.  Farrow, A. Akinyemi, F.O. Machete, R.L. Kayombo, B. Tuyishimire, J. Mubea, K. & Michael, W. (2023). Satellite Data for Improved Monitoring of Farm Productivity and Early Warning Systems in Botswana. Policy Brief Botswana, June 2023.

CCARDESA Category

Tomato variety JUPITER

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Date of publication
Edition or Version
1.00
Institution
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Language
Gender marker
Youth marker
Description/Abstract

The Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute, through its new variety introduction and evaluation programme, have identified a tomato variety Jupiter adapted to both humid and sub-humid regions of the island. Jupiter is a semideterminate cooking tomato variety with high-yielding potential and suitable for both fresh market and processing. The plant bears long oblong fruits which are preferred by growers and highly appreciated by consumers.

Keywords
Tomato, JUPITER
Contact name (for further information)
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Contact institution (for further information)
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Citation

FAREI, (2022). Tomato variety JUPITER. Mauritius VOD/2022/1 R ev1.0

CCARDESA Category

Onion Variety 243

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Date of publication
Edition or Version
1.00
Institution
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Language
Gender marker
Youth marker
Description/Abstract

Onion 243 is a short-day yellow hybrid variety with high yield potential and is suitable for storage. Plants have a uniform fall over of leaves at maturity. Bulbs are globular, uniform, medium-sized, and firm. Yield is comparable to hybrid varieties which are commercially cultivated locally. The variety adapts well to onion-growing regions except in coastal areas having sandy soil.

Keywords
Onion Variety 243
Contact name (for further information)
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Contact institution (for further information)
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Citation

FAREI, (2022). Onion Variety 243. Mauritius AD/2022/1 Rev 1.0.

CCARDESA Category

Guidelines for Extraction of Tomato Seeds

Content Type
Author or Institution as Author
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Date of publication
Edition or Version
1.00
Institution
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Language
Gender marker
Youth marker
Description/Abstract

Guidelines for Extraction of Tomato Seeds

Contact name (for further information)
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Contact email (for further information)
Contact institution (for further information)
Food and Agricultural Research and Extension Institute (FAREI)
Citation

FAREI, (2022). Guidelines for Extraction of Tomato Seeds.

CCARDESA Category
Subscribe to Agricultural Input, Service Providers and NGOs

Funding Partners

4.61M

Beneficiaries Reached

97000

Farmers Trained

3720

Number of Value Chain Actors Accessing CSA

41300

Lead Farmers Supported